7 Reasons Americans Will Never Embrace Soccer

17 Jul 2008

Written by Athlists

I like my beer cold, my TV loud, and my grill flaming. I’m as red-blooded American as they come, and one of the biggest sports fans you will ever meet. I consider myself a human database of football stats, basketball trades, baseball figures, NASCAR victories, and even the current cricket standings.

There is one sport, however, that has always taken a back burner here in America . . . despite being the most popular game in the world.

Soccer, the beautiful game, futbol, football, or whatever accepted term is used to describe it will never be embraced in America. It’s a sad truth, but it’s a conclusion that’s inevitable and can be completely explained.

Admittedly, my passion for soccer was born my junior year of college while playing FIFA 06 with some roommates. Being junior varsity lacrosse and basketball players, we wanted to test our skills against the best of the best just to find out how tough the game really is. Our competitive intramural team name was FIFA 06 (With Multi-Tap), and we got our asses handed to us in the playoff semi-finals.

So after playing “the beautiful game” on the field, on all gaming consoles, and in arenas, I decided I would take a shot at watching a couple of games on the television. I hate to say it, but I just couldn’t take it. HD didn’t even help.

Although the majority of readers will take offense to this article, just hear me out. There are 7 reasons mainstream America will never embrace this game, and they are absolutely undeniable.

1. Americans don’t have the Attention Spans.

Soccer is a continuous game that is heavily influenced by a team’s endurance and stamina. Unfortunately, Americans do not understand that concept. While one of the most popular sports in the United States involves watching a car go around a track for 600 miles, soccer is players running constantly for 90 minutes. Unlike soccer, however, NASCAR also involves the elements of horrendous crashes, pit stops, and fan favorites. Football also stops after every play, and during the four quarters of the game. The same goes for the innings of baseball, and the quarters of basketball.

2. Low Scores.

Because soccer is such a competitive and trying sport, the scores remain relatively few and far between. Americans like scoring, in all ways, forms, and meanings. Look at every other sport and their average scores, and then compare them to a high scoring soccer affair involving 5 – 6 goals. While scoring a goal is exciting, you have to remember spectators endure 90 minutes of passing balls and running in order to witness the goal.

3. Americans are Fat.

The average weight for American men is 191 pounds, which is 20 pounds heavier than men 40 years ago. The childhood obesity problem doesn’t help either, with nearly 20% of children between the ages of 6 – 12 being overweight. Simple logic will tell you that being overweight means being unhealthy, which probably means you can’t perform well in stamina sports such as soccer. Other sports, however, rely on the big man to take the post, block and tackle, or mash a bomb out of the park. Soccer’s not a big man’s game . . . and a nation’s sports interest that is fixed in an unhealthy lifestyle will likely focus on sports that don’t require healthiness or losing weight.

4. There are no Individuals in Soccer.

Although there are players like Henry, Ronaldinho, and Ronaldo the majority of great players and teams rely on teamwork more than any other sport in existence. Football, baseball, and basketball can all stand to have a weak link during game play. Although the weakest link can be exploited in these sports, the offense does not suffer from their mishaps and great players can more than make up for them. Players like Peyton Manning, Lebron James, and Randy Johnson can single handedly take over the game and produce a win. However, soccer requires extreme teamwork and patience. One weak link could mean a collapse in offense as well as defense. Americans like a hero . . . and it’s hard to be a hero on the soccer field without losing it for the team.

5. The Lack of Stats.

In all athletics, stats are crucial for the sports junkie. Being able to rattle off batting, FG, or QB ratings bring joy to millions of Americans. In soccer, the only real stats are passes, tackles, goals, and saves. Of course there are the occasional corners and cards, but the stats simply aren’t as meaningful nor interesting as other mainstream American sports. I could not tell you the passing percentage of Spain in the UEFA Cup, but I can tell you the ERA of most NL pitchers. The same goes for most of Americans that follow any sport closely.

6. No Rivalries in America.

The MLS boasts an unimpressive 16 teams in 16 cities here in America. There are only 2 conferences, and their marketing has done little to focus on city rivalries. In other sports we have Carolina v. Duke, New York v. Boston, USC v. UCLA, and so on. In the MLS, there is hardly any gut wrenching rivalries to partake in. No, Houston vs. Dallas does not count . . . does the nation stop to watch these two teams battle? I think not. In Europe it is the complete opposite, where hundreds of teams have city rivals, as well as their country rivals. Until there’s some flare, American soccer will remain on the back burner.

7. Americans love exactness.

When a player drops a football, fans scream. They also do the same for dropped baseball, pucks, basketballs, or even when a NASCAR driver misses his line and falls behind. We love perfection and our team never turning the ball over. Which explains why Americans could become very frustrated while watching a game of soccer. Because the soccerball is handled by the feet and can be extremely hard to control, precision is hard to come by during a match.

46 Responses to 7 Reasons Americans Will Never Embrace Soccer

Avatar

MT

July 17th, 2008 at 09:35

I completely agree, but you should also add how soccer players (even the good ones) tend to flop. Americans prefer the athletes as warrior image and don’t appreciate the injury faking that goes on in soccer.

Avatar

Chandler

July 17th, 2008 at 09:53

O my this is probably the worst post I have ever seen on here. All generalizations and extreme stretches of facts.

Avatar

Joe

July 17th, 2008 at 15:24

Comparing NASCAR or baseball to soccer is unfair. Even Americans think they’re boring sports.

Games such as football and basketball are much better than soccer, though. You forgot to mention that you actually run much more on a basketball court than you ever will in a soccer field. It’s a known fact, actually, soccer is a sedentary sport for most roles. Sports like football and basketball are also played at a much higher intensity than soccer. While every player participates in a play in basketball/football, 30% of the team does in soccer, therefore proving wrong your “you run more when you play soccer than other sports” theory.

Avatar

Matthew

July 17th, 2008 at 19:00

You know, hockey is very similar to soccer in the way its played (continuous play, goal in net, etc). Why do Americans care more about hockey then soccer?

Avatar

Rich

July 18th, 2008 at 04:51

Who would invent a sport where you can’t use your hands?

And when you CAN use your hands (throwing the ball overhead from the foul line) you have to throw it like a girl.

I agree – really bad post choice. IMHO.

Avatar

Joe

July 18th, 2008 at 05:19

^Agreed. Gay sport. Period.

Avatar

Chicago

July 18th, 2008 at 09:36

You make some excellent points. I, an American soccer fan, admit that it is extremely difficult to sit through an entire match fully engrossed. I have a different theory for this, however, because the idea that we Americans have a much weaker attention span than the rest of the world is wearing thin on me.

It is this: Americans, by and large, are NOT WORLD CLASS FANS. World class supporters, yes, but first class fanatics, not even close.

A close look at fan bases will prove this.

For American (professional sports) fans, a game is a place to take in a game androot when prompted by the scoreboard or when the action on the playing field calls for it. At other times, the status quo is to relax.

For the majority of footy fans, being a fanatic is a sport in itself. Getting prepared and celebrating matchday, and this is important, is ALMOST ENTIRELY NON-CONTINGENT on how well the team is playing. You dress up in scarves, shirts and hats, and go ape shit for 90 minutes (and indeed well after that).

Now I know I’m referring specifically to ultras here, but regular fans as well support to support, not just because a team is doing well or not.

Americans are just not used to this concept at all, but changes are taking place. Many MLS teams have ultras groups, Section 8, Barra Brava, to name a few, as does the National Team (Uncle Sam’s Army).

I truly believe that making the fan experience less passive does wonders as far as sitting through entire matches, even 0-0 draws.

Besides, it’s fun as hell. Americans are catching on, and will catch on, as the evidence is showing. Give us time.

Avatar

Aarin

July 18th, 2008 at 15:54

This could have done without the fatkid youtube linkup. Rather random and not exactly clever in its own execution. Distracting and added nothing. /shrug

Avatar

Jax Maxton

July 18th, 2008 at 17:57

To the poster at #8 – I disagree with a lot of what you said. See college football.

Avatar

Chicago

July 19th, 2008 at 11:41

To the poster at #10

Stop proving this article right about short attention spans. I specifically mentioned that I was referring only to professional sports teams fans.

I, for one would know about college fandom, being a Mizzou student and a college sports reporter. It’s not just football either. See Cameron Crazies.

Avatar

inky

July 20th, 2008 at 13:37

O man, HOCKEY. Dude, watch a few games. You won’t even realize you’ve been holding your breath until you start turning blue. It’s the high stamina sport AND it’s exciting!

Avatar

joe

July 20th, 2008 at 16:55

What an arrogant and ignorant post. Your lack of understanding is obviously displayed.

Avatar

Sjak

July 20th, 2008 at 21:26

Some british guy guest on an american talkshow said that attending a game og american sports reminded him of a picnic. Lots of eating and breaks in the game to buy food and chat. A soccer match is much shorter than baseball and football matches and can be harder to make a day out of it. soccerfans have to hang out in pubs before and after a game to make a day out of it.

I don´t agree with the part about the lack of stars or heroes in soccer. I think best soccer players are just as well known as the stars of football or baseball. I think worldwide Beckham and Ronaldo are much more recocnized names than Manning or Favre. I think the salary cap in some of the american sports make it harder to become stars.

I think you are right about reason number 2 and 5. Thats some of the major problems with soccer. I like american football because of the stats and because there is more than one way to get points. I just can´t get through a whole match because of all the bloody breaks and game stops in it. Maybe it feels different if you are there at the stadium.

Don´t know about nr. 7. Never thougth about it that way. They bought beckham who are known for his precision. Might be something about that.

And why would soccer not catch on i USA? Some years ago it was the country with the most registered soccerplayers in the world. Don´t know if that is true today though.

I think it would be more relevant to see a 7 reasons why baseball is being replaced with soccer.

Avatar

Chicago

July 21st, 2008 at 08:22

Besides, I think that our so-called fascination with scoring works well with soccer. Getting chances and scoring goals are usually extremely dramatic and unpredictable. They don’t come cheap, that’s for sure. So when a goal IS scored, it is that much more exhilirating.

As for the much maligned 0-0 draw, I just saw Chicago Fire and Real Salt Lake play to a 0-0 draw in front of a rowdy packed house. Guess what? It was fun as hell. There were many great chances to score and we were all on our feet for just about the whole game; it was that intense. While some goals would have been nice, it was a much better feeling that we didn’t lose with no goals, than if we had lost with five goals scored.

You really need to have a vested interest in a certain team to get into watching soccer on TV. It’s really like any other sport. As a Sox, Bears, Blackhawks, and Bulls fan, I really can’t sit through many entire regular season games that my teams aren’t playing in. I just have little to no interest. Same with soccer.

Avatar

Stoo

July 24th, 2008 at 07:41

This is an absolute disgrace of a post. Pure twaddle displaying another American’s complete lack of knowledge about the sport.

Avatar

davidhra

July 25th, 2008 at 17:01

At post 3

It is absolute nonsense to say that soccer is sedentary. Sure, when it’s palyed by amateurs in the park it is but if you watch a proper game, say in the English Premier League – not MLS – you will notice that players never stop moving. They are constantly re-adjusting positions, reacting to the other teams movement on the pitch.

Nike put a chip in a player’s boots to measure his work-rate. Over the course of the 90 minutes he ran over 10 miles and was at rest for less than 30.” And he was a striker- the guy paid to hang around up front waiting for the ball. Midfield players cover even greater distances.

And to say that one sport is better than enough is foolish. Football, basketball and soccer all have their finer points.

Avatar

revspr

July 26th, 2008 at 10:10

IMHO soccer it’s actually played by most people around the world (everyone is more involved with it), football hockey, etc.. are better described as spectator sports, so the stops ans scores make more sense in TV (and that’s why soccer looks lame in comparison)

Avatar

blah blah

July 26th, 2008 at 15:39

This is the gayest article I have ever read in my entire life. 1st of all they dont let fat people play in pro soccer so that doesnt matter. And yes we know that soccer doesnt have individuals because its a team sport. Duh. Scores dont matter and neither do attention spans. There are many rivalries between america and other countries. If u would pull ur head out of ur ass maybe u would see that.
Ur article sucks. ty :)

Avatar

Fat Mike

August 7th, 2008 at 12:57

Point 2 made about the scores… Sure in soccer you get 0-0 draws, but they can actually be exciting. Basketball can seem too much like I have a go, you have a go, running back and forward to each other’s net. You fully appreciate the skill in defence needed to keep a clean sheet when you have played any amount of soccer yourself.
You of course get scores like 5-0, 3-3…I think it’s easy to forget in football one converted touchdown is equal to 7 points and a game scoring 35-0 or 21-21 would been seen as fairly high scoring.
Manchester Utd for instance scored 80 goals this season, with 22 against, and they played 38 games, this is not including champions’ league, FA cup, and carling cup tournaments.
Teams always have their superstars that can change and control the pace of the game. To suggest there are no heroes in soccer is ridiculous.
I can fully admit there are some playacting sissy girls in the game, but soccer without ‘challenges’ and video judges means fouls unseen by the ref will go unpunished, players over act in hope of drawing the foul to get the field position, it’s unfortunate and can ruin a game. That isn’t to say all players are involved in it.
I do believe the stats are an aspect lacking from the sport which other American sports do play heavily into. This is being gradually introduced more with player ratings, team ratings, and after match video analysis. The truth of the matter IMHO is the exciting part of any sport should be the actually on field action; something which soccer supplies for 2, 45min periods uninterrupted.
Soccer is the most popular game (to watch and play) on the planet for a reason. It is getting more popularised in America and will be embraced. I for one can’t wait…of course if it’s lacking the physical contact of football, there’s always rugby!

Avatar

Marie

August 12th, 2008 at 19:15

i am an american. this country is fat and ignorant.
baseball players and football players are just a bunch of overpaid fatasses.
americans cant handle putting time and money into a sport where they cant be the best in the world.
it disgusts me that the national baseball tournament is called the “world series”. guess what. its not. noone else plays the dumbass sport of baseball any where else in the world because it doesnt take any athletic ability to play. so if u win? its like being the tallest midget. NOONE FUCKING CARES.
superbowl winners shouldnt call themselves world champions. they should call themselves pathetic losers.
i cant wait to move to europe.

Avatar

cufc

August 13th, 2008 at 07:18

you people dont get it and never will stick to your passionless franchised crap and leave real football alone

Avatar

business web site hosting

September 16th, 2008 at 08:26

Great post ! I want to know when you update your blog, where can i subscribe to your blog? :) :) :)

Avatar

Alba

September 17th, 2008 at 16:55

yo digo q se vayan a la verga todos.

arriba el soccer. ;)

Avatar

J-Fitz

September 25th, 2008 at 08:20

You, my friend, are a Class-A RETARD.

Soccer is boring, gay, and a pathetic excuse for a sport. It’s the most dull thing I’ve EVER seen in my entire life.

All soccer “fans” think that it’s the best sport because you run around more. Do you REALLY think that running around makes something a sport?

Like you stupid Europeans always say about America and soccer, you only don’t like our sports because you suck at them.

SOCCER SUCKS

Avatar

Jack

October 22nd, 2008 at 08:17

professional baseball teams names…

. (Blogger now has backlinks – very similar to the trackback feature in Movable Type. The term is used colloquially for any kind of Linkback….

Avatar

America.......Not Number 1....... In Anything....... lol.. - Page 8 - Rap GodFathers Community

October 30th, 2008 at 04:03

[...] And Americans, consciously or not, know that all too well……and they can’t stand it. 7 Reasons Americans Will Never Embrace Soccer | The Best Article Every day YouTube – American Soccer Skills 3 close thread __________________ I’m not the shooter, I’m [...]

Avatar

America.......Not Number 1....... In Anything....... lol.. - Page 9 - Rap GodFathers Community

October 30th, 2008 at 04:05

[...] let me jump in this bitch real quick Why America Hates Soccer Leading the Next Inquisition 7 Reasons Americans Will Never Embrace Soccer | The Best Article Every day YouTube – American Soccer Skills 3 close thread what the fuck did that homo do that was so [...]

Avatar

Pele

December 8th, 2008 at 18:18

I think America has two classes of people.Great, open minded, and clearly educated thinkers, and then a majority of lowly close-minded people who wouldn’t even locate Mexico on the world map…. One of my greatest world cup moments come with watching USA getting beat.

Avatar

Fifa

December 8th, 2008 at 18:32

Homosexuality is more popular than soccer in the USA, thats a fact.The real reason why Americans will never embrace soccer is the same reason why the rest of the world will never see homo-sexuality in as much positive light as Americans see it.Sissies!!!Obviously, Americans wouldnt field well in soccer matches after a good night of thier more popular gay romps…for obvious reasons.

Avatar

Chris

December 21st, 2008 at 14:32

This article is gay.

Avatar

AJ

January 3rd, 2009 at 10:52

“It’s a known fact, actually, soccer is a sedentary sport for most roles. ”

The average players runs between five and six miles per game and they only get to rest at the half, during penalties/injuries, or if they’re taken off the field. There may only be 30% of the players near the ball at any given time, but the rest of the team is constantly trying to mark up or get into passing position. All players (aside from the goalkeeper) are continually covering ground.

The reason Americans don’t like soccer isn’t because it’s boring, it’s because a) Americans have little patience for anything short of consistent victory – even for teams they love; b) it’s hard to follow English or European league soccer in the states (on TV, anyway); c) there are tie games; d) because we have a subconscious distaste for all other countries (we don’t even like Canada and it’s just about the same country); and most of all, e) lack of marketing. American culture is based on advertising and soccer isn’t profitable here.

Every sport is an acquired taste. Most football fans love football because they were raised on it. The same is true of soccer – not a lot of kids in the states are raised watching Champions League matches. The rest of those who truly do make up their own minds about which sports they like just have different preferences. I spent most of my life bored to death with all American sports. The attention span argument is true, but it’s entirely subjective. Sports like football and baseball are incredibly boring to me. I don’t have the attention span to watch something that requires one hour for the game and three hours mixed in for between-play and commercial breaks.

About scoring – American culture is based on instant gratification. We want to see points on the board. But if you really get into watching good soccer (not MLS), the buildup and anticipation is way more exciting. The fact that even getting that ball into the net just once could turn the entire game gets you jumping out of the seat when it’s even remotely close to the net. Furthermore, it’s not predictable. Offense and defense switch so rapidly, you never know who could score or when.

I’ll admit the injury faking is a turn-off, but the players do it not because they aren’t tough guys but in order to sway a penalty decision – soccer is a game where even the slightest advantage can get you the one goal you needed for the win and due to the flow of game, the reffing is relatively subjective. And if you think nobody really gets hurt in soccer, click the URI.

Avatar

Alex Abate

January 16th, 2009 at 21:52

That Soccer Hooligans Photo is mine. Please give me credit and link to the original or remove it from your blog.

http://www.flickr.com/photos/sandrino/209714180/

Avatar

Andre

April 21st, 2009 at 21:15

Hey J-Fitz, fuck you, I am an American but everything you just said proves how ignorant you are. You are the red neck the world sees us as, saying shit like soccer is “gay” and “stupid europeans.” The only reason you don’t like soccer is because it requires skill, fitness, and endurance. I’d like to see one of your football players try to sprint non-stop for 90 minutes. Soccer owns and all Americans like you know it. I agree with Marie, I can’t wait to move to Europe.

Avatar

Chris

May 24th, 2009 at 21:34

Do any of you understand how much skill it takes to do what footballers do.

David Beckham can place a ball on a penny from about 60 yards away, using his feet.
All your sports involve your hands. I’m not saying i can throw it like them, but comparing it with the feet it’s a lot harder to kick.

Go on Youtube and watch skill videos, with the likes of Ronaldo, Ronaldinho and Henry. They do it with their feet, then you try doing anything close to it.

Avatar

ian

May 29th, 2009 at 20:46

soccer is for pussies

Avatar

ian

May 29th, 2009 at 20:49

Andre, your an idiot.
soccer can not compare to the physical requirements of football. Soccer is for fairies and any soccer player would be destroyed by any football player. Football is a real man’s sport. Go ahead and move to Europe, one less bitch in our country.

Avatar

ian

May 29th, 2009 at 20:52

and Marie. you are a dumbass, as well.
Football players are more athletic, physically fit, tougher, stronger, and any other adjective you can fathom to describe a real man. Soccer is a bitch “sport” with nothing but running up and down a field kicking balls at eachother. I wouldn’t be surprised if they all start doing what they are used to and catching the balls in their mouths.

Avatar

J.T.

June 4th, 2009 at 08:22

>I, for one would know about college fandom, being a Mizzou student and a college sports reporter. It’s not just football either. See Cameron Crazies.

You still wouldn’t know unless you’ve been to a big game down South.

>One of my greatest world cup moments come with watching USA getting beat.

But we really don’t give a shit! That is why the world gets pissed at us for not liking soccer. They want to rub it in our face that they beat us, but it’s not all that fun when we don’t care (if we even know) that we lost.

>fuck you, I am an American but everything you just said proves how ignorant you are. You are the red neck the world sees us as, saying shit like soccer is “gay” and “stupid europeans.” The only reason you don’t like soccer is because it requires skill, fitness, and endurance. I’d like to see one of your football players try to sprint non-stop for 90 minutes. Soccer owns and all Americans like you know it. I agree with Marie, I can’t wait to move to Europe.

I’ll try to refrain from getting pissed at the way you use a classist, bigoted term like redneck. I’d like to see one of your soccer players take a full speed hit from a 300 pound lineman get up and do it again. Basketball requires skill, fitness, and endurance. So does football, a different kind of endurance, the kind where you get tackled play after play and keep doing it. Americans don’t “know soccer owns”. We don’t really like it. Go move to Europe. We don’t give a shit.

Here’s the thing about soccer. You play for 90 minutes and the score ends up 0-0 quite frequently. And, they may try penalty kicks, but a lot of times they just leave it there. What the hell was the point of the game? You stay exactly where you started. To say we don’t like soccer because we are too stupid is also absurd. Soccer is pretty much the simplest team sport there is. They don’t even stop the clock, which gives basketball another dimension.

Us being doesn’t really have anything to do with it either. A lot of Americans play soccer, just very few watch it. It’s actually the most played sport by American kids, they just more often get into baseball, basketball, or football later on.

I’m not going to say soccer sucks, and I’m certainly not going to say it doesn’t require a lot of skill, because it does, though I don’t see how it requires any more skill than most other sports. I just don’t understand what makes it so great. Honestly, if I went to Britain, I’d find the fans more entertaining than the game.

Avatar

tom

June 12th, 2009 at 20:36

fair enough jt…thats the best attitude i’ve heard from someone who doesn’t like the game of soccer…

you make it clear that you don’t know much about soccer so you won’t make too strong of judgements on it…i appreciate that attitude…

to the rest of the people bashing soccer here with comments like, “soccer is for pussies”…

when you say things like that you honestly aren’t embarrased by yourself?…thats something a 13 year old would say. did your brain never develop or what?

you may not like soccer but to discredit it as an easy sport or pussy sport is just stupid…sure its not even close to as physical as football or rugby, but its still way more physical than baseball or basketball…anybody been watching the nba playoffs… a finger on a players back equals a technical fould nowadays…and since when did a sports “toughness” determine whether a sport is good or not…i suppose gladiators were the best athletes of all time using that logic?

and to the person who said soccer is a sendantary sport…wow just wow, i have a hard time believing someone can know so little about a sport yet comment on it so confidently as if they know what they’re talking about…its comical at best…in a face to face argument you would embarrass yourself…luckily any old idiot can post ridiculous things over the internet. and in my experience thats the one thing i hate about the internet…

you discover there are a whole lot more idiots in the world than you thought…

Avatar

David Beckham's Right Foot

June 30th, 2009 at 13:11

I think it just comes down to the fact that every person has their own likes and dislikes. What is so complicated about that?

I like certain types of music and I don’t like others. So what? I can’t tell you exactly why I like them, I just do. They appeal to me for some reason, that’s all. I don’t really care why other people agree or disagree with my preferences. If they like baseball, that’s great – whatever makes them happy. If they hate soccer, fine, don’t watch it. Everyone is different and why try to force people to like or dislike something they already have an opinion on?

Also, it’s even sillier to try to explain why a group of MILLIONS have a certain opinion. There’s just no collective reason. They all have their own reasons. Maybe it’s just because we, as Americans, have a different sports culture than other countries, so we naturally gravitate towards the sports we are constantly exposed to while growing up. The rest of the world does the same thing.

Really, I don’t care if most Americans don’t like soccer (football). It’s not like the sport is going to suffer from it! It’s all over TV nowadays and there are a million and a half ways to watch it online. I’ll keep watching it and ignore the sports I don’t care about. I’m not going to make fun of those other sports or put down their fans or players. It’s just counterproductive.

Avatar

Logan

August 12th, 2009 at 19:36

Ok I’m not going to blab on about how “Soccer’s for pussies” or “football player’s are lethargic” and all of this but I have to ask why can’t anyone take at least somewhat of a neutral view? Alright so soccer players arn’t as tough as an NFL lineman and could never stand getting actually checked/tackled but an NFL lineman could NEVER keep moving constantly for 45 minutes. This is because he is trained differently, he is trained to go fast and hard for a very short amount of time while soccer players are trained to move at a jogging pace for 45 minutes at a time, it’s all about how you train. NFL players are given very little credit by soccer fans because they hardly move and they arn’t good athletes and all this stuff, but I would like to see a soccer player just try to tackle a pro Quaterback even, just try. Both athletes are amazing but they are trained differently, it takes a lot of skill to come straight off the line with about a 2 foot start and knock your opponent down, it also takes a lot of skill to beam a ball top shelf from 20 yards away. Everyone is so caught up in which sport is better that they won’t even consider how goo the other athletes are. I mean no matter what the sport I doubt any of you even has the slightest chance of competing with a pro in it. Now come on have a discussion don’t just constantly slam the other sport.

Avatar

Norman

August 19th, 2009 at 22:50

Soccer is occasionally enjoyable to watch, when the camera pulls back far enough so I can see the flow of the game. But watch it in a stadium-never. No matter how hard I try I just cannot care about it. Boring mmmm perhaps a better term would be subtle like baseball. The winning is in the details.

Imagining a scenario in which soccer becomes a major sport in the US is next to impossible. Now it might happen in 50 years but not in 10.

Avatar

Mr. Speaker

September 29th, 2009 at 00:27

I would like to say that “Joe” is a complete tool. Clearly he lacks any experience in playing a game of soccer, or else, he plays like a tard. There is hardly ever a time in the game of soccer where you should be standing still. True, you don’t have the ball very often at all. But you should be making runs to get the ball, to create space for who has the ball, or to draw a defender away. If the opposing team has the ball, you should be running with your check (who unless he plays like “Joe” will be running), chasing the ball down, or hauling ass to get back and defend. The only position that doesn’t run throughout a game is the keeper. At a professional level, the average midfielder, over a full ninety minutes, will run 12-15km. This is sprinting, jogging and walking, but personally, i’d like to see an american walk 2-5km without worrying about a ball and 20 other guys on the field.

Avatar

neutral

October 28th, 2009 at 06:52

why are we arguing i like both sports and they both require alot of skill i have a little analogy for people who like to argue, ” arguing over the internet is like running in the special olympics, you may win but your still retarded” not trying to offend mentally handicapped people but stop arguing and admit that both sports are hard as fuck to play and get on with your life. ty =D

Avatar

TB

November 5th, 2009 at 22:49

Now when you think your attention span, NASCAR is worthless, watching a car go around in circles for 3 hours and crashes happen rarely, thats just stupid. And football, very manly, a 6 second sprint followed by a 5 minute wait just to do another 6 second sprint.

ian, you look at most football players, notice how many of them are fat asses that can barely run, how is that more physically fit?

Avatar

HBDK

November 6th, 2009 at 07:50

I happen to love both American Football and football (soccer).
I have played soccer for 25 years, and are now in my 30s. As an adult soccer is a very fun sport to play. You are active, and have responsibilities through 90 minutes of play. I hate being on the bench/sideline, (just like Allan Iverson in basketball) and it is much fun to be involved.
Soccer is a lot about skill and endurance, and very team-oriented just like football.

I am also very much into football, so I will try to explain some simularities, and some insights into the mechanisms of soccer.
Teamwork is necessary in order to move the ball and set up your team mates, who are in a better position than you. No running back can outspeed 11 defenders for a TD, but if his teammates blocks well it might happen. The same goes for soccer, where Messi (the best individual player in the game) can be double-teamed and closed down for must of the match. However, if his teammates are also skillful and can get into a good position with the ball on their own, then the opponent is in trouble. Just like basketball/football’s “pick your poison”.
Skills with your feet and understanding of the game (soccer IQ) is required for all 11 players, otherwise you will loose the ball to the opponent way to quickly. This is a problem because, it is more enduring to play defense than offense, particalurly against teams with very gifted players. When the opponnent has many gifted players (like the Spanish national team), then your team needs to more much and cover a lot of ground in order to protect being exploited by the opposition. After 60 minutes of running around chasing the ball you will create more and more space and time for your opponents to set up a goal.
Okay, hence that controlling and passing skills are important, because it is better to keep the ball to give your defense and midfield a break. This is very simular to football, where you don’t want 3-and-outs which could eventually expose your defense that gets tired.
Turnovers are not just turnovers…
It is far better to create a takeaway close to the opponent’s goal rather than in your own zone. Doesn’t this sound familiar to football.

Soccer IQ is about understanding the dynamics of the game. When and which teammate is in a suited position, and what situation increases the chances of scoring. Every soccer player has decisions to make when possesing the ball, just like the quarterback has to scan the field.
Soccer IQ is also like basketball, where anybody can take a shot at the ring but where you would rather have Shaq take a shot near the basket, than setting him up for a 3-pointer, right. The same goes for soccer, where you want to set up your best players for a goal chance.

A succesfull 90-yard-drive for a touchdown normally requires even a few running plays, and short passes for no gain. However, your team is “on a mission”. The same goes for midfield play in soccer. When distributing the passes, and passing the ball around is like waiting for the opponent to open up. Much like running the ball in football will make the defense play “honest”.
Yes, there are not that many goals in a soccer match (typically an average of 2,5/per game), but again in football you will often have a quarter with only a field goal or even scoreless, and maybe just 2 or 3 TDs in a game.
Yet I love watching both football or soccer (on TV or at the stadium).
Soccer is more joyful to watch, if you appreciate good ball handling skills, teamwork and climax (goals!).
Football is more tactical (many in-game coaching decisions), more explosive (big collisions) and has more suspense/drama.
Both sports can be highly unpredictable with deflected shots at goal, muffed punts, turnovers, you name it.
Many believe that soccer is just about running and kicking the ball around.
But the margin of error is in fact very small, particalurly if it occurs in the wrong parts of the field, or if the opponent is able to exploit it quickly. A defensive error from one player, or a missed chance in front of the goal can end up costing the entire game. This is a little like a defensive TD’s or special team TDs can be game-breaking in football.
You have “a window of oppertunities” in soccer, and you need to capitalize from it, in order to succeed. The more dominant you play your opponent the bigger the “window” gets.

Which sport is more “manly”. Football is definitely more physical, however in order to play soccer, you need to be able to run freely, and wrecklessly like a wide receiver or cornerback. However the hits you do take in soccer match are fewer. But those you do take are flying two-feet tackles, high-speed collisions with the oppenents goalkeeper or brutal central backs, or jumping battles in heading situations, where elbows are flying high too. And this without any real protection.
After every 90-minute-match I have played in my career apart from being sore in my whole body from all the running and movements, I have always taken a few hits on my legs, head, rips etc. You need at least 2-3 days to recoup, but it is true that it takes longer in football. Basketball, hockey etc. can be played every day. This is definitely not possible in soccer. I guess that explains a lot.

Soccer is not a sissy/gay sport as you can definitely intimidate your opponnent with physical play, and end the other guy’s season with one deliberate dubious tackle.

I hope this explanation have enhanced the chances for some of you who did not understand the fascination of soccer. But I still LOOOOVE watching football too.. :-)

Comment Form

Subscribe Our Feed